Project 5) Is the sterilization protocol too harsh?

Endophyte 3.0 (SH, AQ, more?)

Answer: Maybe.

Experiment

We compared our Standard protocol to a modified protocol. From the same leaf, we

1) cut disks → surface sterilize as usual →  plated

AND

2) cut a large piece of leaf → surface sterilized → THEN cut disks with a (sterile) cork borer.

Results

The data are scattered, particularly in terms of total fungi scored (Table ). Except for the student 2 experiment, each experiment looks internally consistent. Taking the data in the aggregate: with the standard protocol 75% of the disks were negative and with the modified protocol, 62%. These numbers are both high compared to previous experiments, but still are close to each other. Overall there does not seem to be a significant difference between the modified and standard protocol (chi square?)

Table: Modified vs. standard surface-sterilization